Call us now on

0800 201 4811

Expert Advice: How to Tell if An Antique is Valuable

Gina Narramore

Gina Narramore



McCarthy & Stone have spoken to James Constantinou from Prestige Pawnbrokers and TV’s Posh Pawn who gave us some top tips around how to identify an antique and tell if it’s valuable.

Antiquing is one of the UK’s favourite hobbies and it’s easy to see why. The pastime can be both exciting and profitable - you only need to look at stories like this from a 2015 car boot sale where a young couple of Beanie Baby enthusiasts in Cornwall bought a Princess Diana memorial Beanie Baby for £10, knowing it could sell for up to £62,000.

However, while money can be made from buying and selling antiques, for many the hobby is also about craftsmanship, nostalgia and personal connections to items.

What’s more, of everyone in the UK, people of retirement age are the most likely to have an antique in their possession. So, to help you both decide whether you potentially own any antiques and to look for any signs that they might be of value, we spoke to expert James Constantinou – the star of Channel 4's Posh Pawn and the Founder and CEO of Prestige Pawnbrokers & Prestige Luxury Boutique.

Interview with James Constantinou

Can you tell us what exactly is an ‘antique’? 

Typically, an antique is an item of value, significance or interest that is over 100 years old. There are many items of value and interest that don’t qualify as antique and are instead referred to as vintage.

In conversational language, and even in sales and marketing materials, these terms have become somewhat interchangeable. But, when it comes to appraising items, it’s important for us to get this right.

Dating an item is often a critical component of the appraisal process, and in some instances just a few years can have a significant impact on the amount of money we are able to offer for an item. 

What are some of the most common household items that might be antiques?

A lot of our customers ask us how to identify an antique, and this can be a very difficult question to answer. At Prestige, we most commonly see antique jewellery in our stores. From rings through to cufflinks, many households will include an item of antique jewellery that may be worth a lot more than its owner anticipates.

We also see lots of antique timepieces, including both wrist and pocket watches, with early Cartier pieces always piquing our interest. In terms of household items, we often see antique art, silverware and furniture. 

How can you tell if an antique is valuable?

Identifying an antique item is about both proving and disproving its age. So, signs of modern-day manufacturing processes or materials immediately indicate that something is likely to be a replica rather than an original antique.

In the trade, we often use Bradbury’s Book of Hallmarks to assist in ageing and valuing jewellery, flatware and similar items. Sometimes, we can also rely on signatures, authentication cards or a service history.

With the majority of antiques, you would expect to see some signs of wear and tear or ageing. For example, this could be light damage on a painting, or microscopic scratches on a piece of gold.

To help identify whether an item is an antique or not, it’s important to utilise any expertise you have around you. I’m incredibly lucky to have a team that specialise in specific areas.

We often see antique instruments and we have an expert in that area to appraise and value these before we offer our customers a purchase price or loan rate.

How can you help keep antiques in the best condition to add value?

One of the most important things in terms of the value of antiques is the ability to provide provenance. So, if you do have an item of value, be sure to keep hold of any paperwork or anything that can prove the history of the piece.

Original and additional parts also have an impact on value, along with the overall condition of a piece. For example, keeping art or furniture out of natural sunlight and away from any sprays or chemicals that may alter their condition is important.

With jewellery, keeping it in its original state typically leads to optimum market value, so it’s advisable to avoid engravings or the addition or omission of stones. If possible, try and keep items in their original boxes and always have them professionally cleaned and cared for.

How do you go about getting an antique valued and sold?

There are many opportunities to have items of value appraised. At Prestige, as well as letting customers buy antiques, we also provide the option to take a loan against antiques, usually for a period of less than a year. This provides customers with a cash injection but also means that customers can retain long-term ownership of their valuable items.

There are lots of other opportunities for you to have your items valued though, and I always think it’s good to keep an eye out for local antique fairs. At these events, you will often find lots of experts and a number of dealers. If you’re lucky, one of these will be looking for the item you are selling. 

Have you ever encountered any particularly interesting items at prestige?

There aren’t many days when something unusual doesn’t come through the doors of one of our six stores! We see lots of both vintage and antique items and we often see items of jewellery that literally take our breath away.

It’s often the tales of items or the reasons for their sale that are of most interest, but I would say that appraising a pair of Queen Victoria’s knickers continues to be one of the most unusual moments of my career.

If you have any antique items you would like valued or are keen to understand the best antique items to buy, you can of course pay us a visit as well and we’ll be happy to help. 

Making an Investment in an Antique: Help and Advice 

If you’re thinking about visiting an antique fair and picking up a few items, then it’s important to follow a process that goes some way to safeguarding a return on your investment.

These top tips will help teach you how to find and pick antiques to add to your collection.

  • Research or Resource

If you are keen to begin investing in antiques, it’s important that you conduct your own research or find a reliable expert to help you make your initial investment decisions. If you are looking to invest in items it’s important that you remain focused on the objective value of an item - both with regards to financial worth and market appeal.

  • Facts and Fakes

Before buying an item, it’s important to perform some basic checks to ensure that the item is not a fake. Secondly, make sure you are armed with the facts, paperwork and any associated provenance details so you are able to sell the item in the future.

  • Interest and Influences

When it comes to investing in antiques, you should have clarity around how quickly you want to sell your item and the type of return you would like to achieve.

With that in mind, you need to evaluate not only the item you are looking to buy but also the market you wish to sell it in. So, ask yourself what the current level of interest is and what, if anything, could influence or affect the demand and therefore the value for this item now or in the future.

  • Quality and Condition

By definition, antique items will have been produced over 100 years ago and so in most instances, some signs of wear and tear will be expected. However, like James suggested, you need to carefully look for any damage, repairs or personalisation (such as engravings), as these will all impact the value of a piece.

If possible, it’s always good to know how well an item has been cared for, cleaned, repaired and stored. Look for signs of damage by light, heat or smoke and take time to examine all items properly before making an offer.

  • Need and Negotiation

As with any deal, try to keep a level head and ensure you remain detached from any passion, excitement or personal interest you have in the item. You should also remember that a seller probably wants to sell an item more than you want to buy it.

So, always negotiate and have the confidence to remain calm and in control when bartering over the cost. Any saving you can make when you buy will allow you to make a further gain when it comes to selling your item.

Antiquing when Downsizing

By following these top tips, you’ll find it easy to identify an antique. If you’re moving into one of our properties, then identifying your antiques and valuable items can be incredibly useful as part of the downsizing process. Plus, by taking up antiquing, you’ll find it easy to make new friends and spend time with like-minded individuals, which can also help you tackle loneliness in retirement.

So, start exploring your home today. You never know what high-value antiques you might uncover.

Related Articles


VE Day 75

On 8th May, 75 years ago, the guns fell silent marking the end of the war in Europe. Millions of people took to the streets to celebrate peace and remember their loved ones.  ...Read more


Hurry to Surrey

A small commute south of London but a million miles from the hustle and bustle of the capital sits rolling countryside, vast woodlands and quaint English villages ...Read more


Beautiful Bistros

Our in-house catering team have been working behind the scenes to bring new services into our Retirement Living PLUS developments for our customers to enjoy ...Read more


Couple Forge New Friendships in Retirement

Leslie and Ann Harpin, 87 and 81 recently made the decision to move to McCarthy and Stone’s Isabella House Retirement Living development in Hertford. The couple are not only enjoying spending more time together, they also have a new group of friends who they refer to as their extended family.  ...Read more


Your Resale Questions Answered

McCarthy & Stone’s Resales Director, David Gabriel has over 20 years’ experience selling preowned retirement properties and heads up our dedicated in-house resales service. ...Read more


Your Retirement Move is Safe in Our Hands 

The loss of a loved one is such an emotional experience for the family without the added stress of them being faced with selling their home. But if you need to sell your property, McCarthy & Stone Resales can take care of everything. ...Read more


McCarthy and Stone Resales Success

McCarthy & Stone Resales is having a positive impact when it comes to supporting those who wish to resell their retirement properties, as well as helping new customers experience what a retirement living lifestyle is all about. ...Read more


Tuning in To Singing in Later Life 

A singing group comprised of retirees from McCarthy & Stone’s Chinnerys Court Retirement Living development in Braintree, is showing how singing lifts the spirits and can be good for your health.  ...Read more


A Tale of Happily Ever After

Good communication, consideration for each other and never going to bed without making up – are the secrets to a long, loving and successful marriage, says homeowners Mr and Mrs Bowhill. ...Read more


£130,000 and Counting

Thanks to your generosity, we have smashed our target for this year’s charity partner Beanstalk. Here's a round up of some of the activities we have been getting up to across the UK. ...Read more


Our Ultimate Christmas Recipes 

We've spoken to our Catering Manager who provides us with his ultimate Christmas recipes for you to try this season. They’re great for putting you in the Christmas spirit, and your friends and family members will love them. ...Read more


Christmas Events – Roundup

We’re hosting a series of ‘At Home’ Christmas events for our residents and their families. Find out more about what’s happening in our roundup blog post.  ...Read more


DIY Christmas Gifts you Still Have Time to Make 

With the countdown to Christmas now on, it’s time to start thinking about Christmas gifts. There are those people who buy and wrap everything by October, and then there’s the rest of us, who possibly leave things till the last minute. Well, why not get organised this year? ...Read more


Christmas Decorating Tips 

To help make your home full of Christmas cheer, we’ve spoken to Clare Gibson, Head of Interior Design at McCarthy & Stone who’s provided her top Christmas decorating tips. ...Read more


Tips for Successfully Downsizing

Many people find that later in life that their home is far bigger than they need. Downsizing can bring a variety of benefits, including both financial and practical ones. That said, it can often be an emotional or difficult time.  ...Read more


Remarkable UK Gardens for Autumn Colour 

Another season has flown by and now the summer heat has faded with the turn of autumn. With the cooler days and longer nights, our gardens are transforming into a rich tapestry of colour, from fiery reds and oranges to majestic golds. ...Read more


Caring for House Plants 

From succulents to spider plants, the demand for indoor foliage is showing no signs of slowing down. No matter what the season, low maintenance house plants are ideal for brightening up the look and feel of a room. ...Read more


Foraging Favourites

For many people, collecting and eating wild plants and fungi has been part of life since childhood, filling punnets with wild edibles from ripening berries to sweet chestnuts. ...Read more


Spotlight on York

A city of extraordinary cultural and historical wealth woven into  every  brick and beam, York seeps history at every turn. ...Read more


Summer Events in 2019 To Look Out For

The summer season is packed with a variety of events to appeal to a range of interests and ages. Savour the delights of new and exciting cuisine, enjoy the thrill of world-class horse racing and discover the latest super cars, at events taking place across the summer months.  ...Read more


It's All Greek To Us

Sparkling white beaches, deep blue seas, sugar-cube villages and venerable ancient sites make the
Greek islands an idyllic holiday destination for many. Tourists can immerse in the Greek cuisine,
century-old sites and local culture each island has to offer, while enjoy luxurious accommodation
and the locals’ warm and welcoming hospitality. ...Read more


Fishing for Fun

Looking for an exhilarating and challenging activity that brings a sense of serenity and calmness? We think we’ve found the perfect catch. ...Read more


It’s time to start living life to the full again

A McCarthy & Stone Retirement Living Plus apartment is about getting more from life for the over 70s. It’s the perfect combination really - company when you want it, help when you could use it, care when you need it. And all in the comfort of your own stylish new home. ...Read more


Staying Cool and Well During A Heatwave

Although warmer weather can be a welcome sight for many, the increased temperatures can lead to
added risks for some, particularly those with health issues or those that are more vulnerable. Stay well with these tips.  ...Read more


The History of Father's Day

Father’s Day is the perfect time to thank fathers and father figures for their help and support. In this post, McCarthy & Stone look at the history of Father’s Day. ...Read more


A New Adventure 

Colin and Pat Mackay are looking forward to making the most of their retirement following their move to North Berwick.

...Read more


The Benefits of Downsizing in Retirement

There are many benefits of downsizing and if this is something you are considering, here, we share our knowledge about downsizing, and explain why it could be one of the best things you can do for your retirement.   ...Read more


Blooming Marvellous: The Chelsea Flower Show

The world-famous RHS Chelsea Flower Show. It’s the most glamorous day out in the gardening calendar.

The grounds of the Royal Hospital Chelsea are once again blooming with flora as the Royal Horticultural Society prepares to welcome 157,000 spectators to their annual five-day flower festival in May. ...Read more


Working After Retirement – Is It For You?

More and more people are choosing to put off their retirement and continue working. Plus, in many other cases, those who have already retired are looking to return to work. Here, we weigh up the pros and cons of each situation. ...Read more


How To Manage Your Diet In Retirement

There are many extra demands placed on our bodies as we progress through life and because of this our nutritional needs also change as a result. It is never too late to revamp your nutrition and nurture your body with a healthier diet.   ...Read more


Tackling loneliness among older people with Pen Pals

We understand the problem of loneliness amongst older people and we want to do something to combat it. That’s why we have created our latest Pen Pals programme, an outlet to connect older people with other older people in communities by the writing and exchanging of letters. Click to find out more. ...Read more


How To Make New Friends In Retirement

Friendship is hugely important at every stage in life, and retirement is no exception. What’s more, in retirement you could make the most of the extra free time you have to discover different experiences and meet new people – leading to new friendships and relationships.  ...Read more


Sheffield – The Steel Centre of the World

Famed for its industry and innovation, the green, modern cityscape now replaces the smoking chimneys from the industrial revolution. There’s a friendly, independent and alternative spirit that can be hard to find in other cities alongside a thriving cultural scene. ...Read more


Wally & The Flying Scotsman

Popular North Gate Court customer Wally Blazey moved into their McCarthy & Stone apartment with his wife Gladys seven months ago, and the couple have just celebrated their 72nd anniversary. At 92, Wally is one of the two last surviving drivers of the Flying Scotsman, the most famous steam locomotive in the world. ...Read more


The Top 11 British Hidden Gems

Where are the best locations in the UK to visit... that you've probably not heard of? We've ranked the best hidden gems around Britain, that are easy to access, and offer a great weekend away with the family. ...Read more


Do Pets Make You Happier?

Whether you're a pet owner or have a pet free home, animals of all kinds have been proven to improve the happiness of their human counterparts. To find out more McCarthy & Stone conducted a survey to see how pets enrich their owners lives. Here are the results! ...Read more